pepita granola with coconut oil and dried cherries

Pepita Granola

Oh I am so tricky with granola, I don’t even know where to begin. Granola is one of those foods that you know you should like because everyone likes it and because it sounds like something that you should like because it has oats and some fruit and overall it’s kind of good for you. And if you like the parts separately, shouldn’t you like the sum of them? Apparently, not if you are me.

pouring the honey

For years, I’ve struggled with my secret granola loathing. Years. I felt pressured to like it because everyone around me did. But I found it either too greasy, or too sweet, or to clumpy or too tough. And sometimes, it would be awfully chewy and it would stick to my upper teeth, which would then cause a wrestling match between my tongue and the pieces that lodged themselves there – and inevitably the pieces would win, and I’d give up. I tried various brands of granola, from the mainstream, to the new and small-batch made, and found nothing that was truly exemplary.

Pepita Granola

But about a year ago, a friend gave me some granola for the holidays and I thought it was delicious. I intended to ask her for a recipe, but kind of never got around to it. I sort of mentally dog-eared it in my head and in my typical way, just forgot.

Pepita Granola

But recently, I’ve been trying to banish the cookie and embrace the healthy. And in my attempts in doing so, I’ve been eating a lot of plain yogurt. Now, I am one of those people who actually loves the taste of plain yogurt (don’t judge me) and won’t eat its flavored cousin, but even yogurt, in all its glory, unadorned by anything, gets a bit dull. And so, in trying to come up with creative yogurt toppings, the idea of granola popped into my head.

Pepita Granola

This recipe came from Smitten Kitchen, which in turn got it from Gourmet, which in turn got it from Calle Ocho, a restaurant in New York. What can I say other than this granola recipe is a keeper? Other than a few tweaks I made based on my personal taste preferences, this is a great recipe to have – it’s not too sweet, not overly oily and if you keep your batch in the freezer, it’ll stay crispy indefinitely. At room temperature, it just gets soft, even in an airtight container.

Pepita Granola

And now I can join the legions of people who actually do like granola because I do as well. And because I am making it, I can add my favorite ingredients, like various dried berries, and make the sum of the parts precisely what I want it to be – plain yogurt, you’ve never tasted better!

**UPDATE 11/24/13: Since many years have passed since I’ve started to make my own granola, I changed up quite a few things and tweaked the recipe for you here. I now make my granola with extra-virgin coconut oil. I can’t stress enough its nutritional properties and it goes so perfectly with the coconut flakes. More importantly, I’ve scaled back sugar considerably. I like granola, but 90% of the time, it’s candy masquerading as healthy breakfast food. In playing around with sugar amounts, I found that decreasing sugar didn’t affect the quality of the granola, but its less sweet taste made it far more exciting to eat. Also, I gave up on using lots of different dried fruit because I much more prefer a pop of tart dried cherries than other fruit and it keeps my pantry less cluttered. (Also, cutting dried apricots is a PITA.) Finally, I added a little nutmeg and scaled up salt (but not by much) because with a proper amount of salt, this granola tastes much better than with just a pinch. In cooking, salt is a great highlighter of flavor – and using just the right amount not only brings a balance to the dish but also creates complexity.

Pepita Granola With Coconut Oil and Dried Cherries

3 cups old-fashioned rolled oats
1 1/2 cup chopped nuts (walnuts, pecans, almonds, what have you)
1 cup unsweetened flaked coconut
1 cup green (hulled) pumpkin seeds, sometimes called pepitas (1 1/2 oz; not roasted)
1/3 cup extra-virgin coconut oil
1/4 cup light brown sugar
3 tablespoons maple syrup
1 teaspoon kosher salt
1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
Punch ground cinnamon
1 cup dried tart cherries

Preheat oven to 300°F; position the rack in the middle. Stir together all ingredients except the cherries and spread the mixture evenly on a half-sheet baking pan. Bake for about 40 minutes, stirring every 10 minutes, or until golden brown and toasted. Transfer to a cooling rack and let cool completely. Stir in dried cherries.


  • cosmic cowgirl

    reminds me a lot of my favorite granola recipe, which i adapted from alton brown. i just use the dry ingredients as a base, then swap out ingredients like local honey for maple syrup, change up the nuts and dried fruit, etc. (i.e. walnuts and sweetened dried bananas tastes like banana nut bread!). i have discovered 325 is the perfect temp and i stir every 10 minutes or so for around 30-40 minutes. and, yes, plain low fat yogurt is THE BEST accompaniment to this treat. great post and pics–yumsville!

  • Amanda

    I was a granola hater for the longest time too. The storebought ones were too sweet, and honestly, I’d rather eat my calories in actual candy. But I tried a martha recipe that was really simply and not too sweet and I liked it. I think what I love most about granola is its texture with smooth yogurt. Gotta love that crunch!

  • Sara

    I totally agree with you about the yogurt–I won’t go near the flavored stuff. Though, besides granola I do add raspberry jam, so perahps it ends up being more sugar that way. I am pretty finicky about granola–if it’s good it’s great but there are a lot (A LOT) of bad granolas out there and the few I’ve liked just are too expensive to justify buying regularly. I’ll have to try this recipe–I made granola a few timees from the Barefoot Contessa cookbook and really it’s easy enough that it’s a shame not to do.

  • Laura

    This recipe looks and sounds amazing! Question: what kind of vegetable oil did you use? Would you ever consider using butter instead of oil? Do you think it would add to the flavor/richness of the granola? thank you!

  • Elizabeth

    I’ve been looking for a good granola recipe and this one seems great! Not too sweet, lots of good things in it! Unfortunately I whipped up a batch tonight and didn’t pay enough attention to it. I checked it at 15 minutes and it was a little golden but I thought, thats way too soon! So I left it another 5 and its a bit burnt here and there :( Definitely salvage-able but will watch more closely next time!

Leave a Comment